# MeshCore Hardware Review: Sanders County Off-Grid Backup Layer (Phase 1)
Prepared 2026-11-22. Full table: `hardware.csv` (24 rows). Status: Assessment/Architecture input.
**Conventions:** "Repo" = github.com/meshcore-dev/MeshCore `main` (last commit 2026-11-14), build envs under `variants/*/platformio.ini`. Latest release: v1.18.0 (2026-10-15; blog.meshcore.io/2026/10/15/release-1-18-0). Flasher: meshcore.io/flasher; repeater config: config.meshcore.io. Prices are web-snippet or vendor-page values from Nov 2026 and move often: **re-quote before budgeting**. "Unknown/unverified" means I did not find a citable source.

## 0. Key findings
1. **Use nRF52840 + SX1262 for every fixed site.** Community measurements (IoTThinks "EasySkyMesh" fork, a *non-official* build: PowerSaving 17 release notes, multimeter readings) show whole-repeater draw of about 6-9 mA (RAK4631 / T114 class) with `powersaving on`, and 0.9-6 mA with RX power saving. ESP32 boards (Heltec V4.2) measured 8-14 mA at best and 50 mA with the FEM always on. Official MeshCore PRs report 5.8-7.5 mA for RAK4631 with `powersaving on` (PR #1238, #2286).
2. **Battery chemistry vs. -30 F (-34 C) is the main risk, not panel size.** Li-ion 18650 can't be charged below 0 C (Seeed spec: charge 0-50 C, discharge -40-60 C). The LiFePO4 packs I found are rated for charge at 0-45/50 C. Some small ones are rated for discharge only at 0-50 C (LiTime 6Ah). Others allow discharge to -20 C (Epoch, Enjoybot, LiTime 100Ah). **-34 C is below every LiFePO4 discharge spec found**, so the plan needs an insulated enclosure and a temperature-logged pilot, not just a bigger battery. Heated packs (Epoch 105Ah: needs a charger supplying at least 0.5 A, resumes charging at 5 C) are large and use solar energy for heat.
3. **Solar in December is about 0.9 kWh/m2/day on a horizontal surface** (NASA POWER climatology at 47.59N, -115.34W, all-sky; Nov 1.27, Dec 0.89, Jan 1.13). That is far below the 2.5 PSH figure used in some northern guides. The NREL PVWatts API returned nothing from the box (DEMO_KEY, no response). **Rerun tilted-array numbers at pvwatts.nrel.gov per site before final design.**
4. **Part 15 / FCC:** 47 CFR 15.247(b)(3) allows 1 W conducted for digital-modulation systems in 902-928 MHz. I verified that text on eCFR. The antenna-gain reduction rules sit in 15.247(b)(4) and (c). I did not verify (b)(4), and (c)(1) I read only covers 2.4 and 5.8 GHz point-to-point. **Verify the following with an FCC-experienced RF engineer or counsel:** (a) a 6 dBi fiberglass omni with 22-30 dBm radios; (b) whether 62.5 kHz LoRa is certified under 15.247 (6 dB BW under 500 kHz) or another rule path; (c) high-gain or PA boards such as Station G2 (36.5 dBm settings in the FAQ) and Ikoka 30/33 dBm. Default advice: stay at 22 dBm radio setting, 6 dBi or lower antenna, and keep the certified configuration.
5. **ESP32 is only for roles that need WiFi** (Heltec V3/V4, RAK3112, Station: WiFi companion, bridges). nRF52 builds have no WiFi companion env.

## 1. Repeater-class hardware (roles from repo envs)
| Board | MCU / radio | TX | Draw (source) | Roles | Price | Cold/power notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **RAK4631 + RAK19007** (WisBlock) | nRF52840 / SX1262 | 22 dBm fw default | Core sleep 2.0 uA, LoRa RX 17 mA, TX@20dBm 125 mA (RAK datasheet). Repeater 6.0 mA powersaving, 0.9-6 mA rxps (IoTThinks fork). | repeater, room, companion USB/BLE, Ethernet variants | Starter kit $19.50-25.70; WisMesh Repeater (RAK10721) $99-299 | Base board charger is TP4054 linear Li-ion, no MPPT (RAK FAQ). The WisMesh Repeater accepts 5-16 V DC but RAK requires a regulated 12 V charger and gives no guarantee for cold-start with an empty battery. Operating temp **unknown**. |
| **RAK3401 + RAK13302 1W** | nRF52840 / SX1262 + PA | 30 dBm HW | unknown | repeater, room, companion USB/BLE | Repeater Mini V2 $89.90-99.90 | 3.2 Ah battery + small panel is not enough for winter. EIRP check needed. |
| **SenseCAP Solar Node P1-Pro (MeshCore)** | XIAO nRF52840 Plus / Wio-SX1262 | 22 dBm | not separately measured | repeater, room, companion BLE/USB | **$100.99** (P1 base $72.90-77.99) | 5 W panel + 4x18650 (13.4 Ah, ~50 Wh), preflashed MeshCore repeater. Charge 0-50 C only. Whether it blocks charging below 0 C is **unverified**. Fixed panel size. |
| **Heltec Mesh Node T114** | nRF52840 / SX1262 | 22 dBm | Sleep 11 uA, TX 164 mA @20dBm 915MHz (datasheet). Repeater 7.9 mA powersaving, 1.6-7.3 mA rxps (fork). | repeater, room, companion BLE/USB | $17.90-33.70 | Operating **-20 to 70 C** (datasheet), below the requirement. Has solar and LiPo connectors. |
| **Heltec MeshSolar** (BMS + HT-n5262M) | nRF52840 / SX1262 | 21+/-1 dBm | Sleep 8 uA, TX 166 mA module-only | repeater, room, companion | $38.99-44.90 | MPPT, 1-4 cell Li-ion or LiFePO4, NTC input. **Discontinued / out of stock** (Heltec docs 2026-11-21). |
| XIAO nRF52840 + Wio-SX1262 (DIY) | nRF52840 / SX1262 | 22 dBm | unknown | repeater, room, companion | unverified | Cheapest DIY; same MCU/radio as P1-Pro. |
| Heltec V4 / V4.3 R8 | ESP32-S3 / SX1262 + FEM | setting 10 dBm gives ~22 dBm; 22 gives ~28 dBm (FAQ 7.7) | V4.2: 50 mA FEM always on, 8-14 mA best case (fork) | repeater, room, companion USB/BLE/WiFi | $21.90 sale (V4.3 R8) | Higher idle draw. Only if WiFi is needed. |
| Heltec T096 | nRF52840 / SX1262 + FEM | 9 dBm setting gives ~22 dBm | 2.8-9.1 mA (fork) | repeater, room, companion BLE/USB | unverified | FEM board; verify RX gain setting. |
| Station G2 / G3 | ESP32-S3 (verify) / SX1262 + PA | FAQ: 1W = 10 dBm setting; max 19 = 36.5 dBm | unknown | repeater, logging repeater, room, companion USB/BLE/WiFi | G2 ~$109 (discontinued), G3 $139 | Part 15 risk at high settings. |
| Ikoka Stick/Nano nRF 22/30/33 dBm | nRF52840 / SX1262 + E22 PA | 1W: set 19; 2W: set 9; "DO NOT EXCEED" | unknown | repeater, room, companion | unverified | Burn-out risk from wrong settings. |
| LilyGO T-Beam 1W, Waveshare ESP32-S3 LR1121, Heltec V3 | ESP32-S3 | various | unknown / ESP32 high | repeater, room, companion | unverified | Not for minimal solar. |

## 2. Companion devices (responders)
| Device | Type | Roles in repo | Price | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **SenseCAP T1000-E** (nRF52840 / LR1110) | phone-paired BLE | companion USB/BLE | $42.99-57.85 | Small, cheap, rugged (verify IP rating); good battery. BLE companion 13-17 mA via USB (fork) | No screen/keyboard; needs a phone with the MeshCore app |
| **LilyGO T-Echo / Plus** (nRF52840) | phone-paired BLE | companion BLE/USB | T-Echo Plus $71.94 | E-paper readable in sun, low draw (Lite: 4.7-13.4 mA) | Slow screen, phone still needed for typing |
| **LilyGO T-Deck / Plus** (ESP32-S3) | standalone screen + keyboard | companion USB/BLE; no room-server env; no WiFi companion env | $61.34 and up (street $78-102) | Works without a phone, GPS/maps | Short battery life, less rugged |
| Wio Tracker L1 | semi-standalone | companion BLE/USB | unverified | Small, screen + joystick | Typing is awkward |
| RAK4631 / Heltec V3 / V4 | phone-paired; V3/V4 also BLE+WiFi (1.18) | companion | see CSV | Cheap, spare-friendly | Bare boards need cases |

Recommendation: T1000-E for most field staff (with the MeshCore phone app), T-Deck Plus for EOC/vehicle/incident command use without phones.

## 3. Room servers
Room server firmware (`*_room_server` envs; release room-server-v1.18.0) exists for nearly every nRF52 and ESP32 board above, **except** T-Deck (no env; repeater env only). It is a BBS for shared posts, not an extra repeater function. Approach: run 1 room server per major ICS/EOC role plus 1 spare, on an nRF52 board (RAK4631 or T114) at a staffed, powered location (EOC, sheriff's office with UPS + solar backup) rather than on a ridge. Ridge repeaters should be repeater-only. A room server costs the same as a repeater in power terms. **Unverified:** room capacity and retention limits. Read config.meshcore.io and docs.meshcore.io before sizing.

## 4. Upcoming / announced (all flagged)
| Item | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Seeed SenseCAP MeshTracker X1 (nRF52840 + LR2021) | In repo and 1.17 notes; field maturity unverified; LR2021 eval kit $119 listed | repo, MeshCore blog 1.17, PR #3112 |
| LR2021-based boards generally | New radio family; unverified for range/draw in MeshCore | Seeed listing |
| Waveshare ESP32-S3 LR1121 | Added in 1.18 | 1.18 notes |
| Heltec V4.3, Tower V2, T096, T190, CT62 | V4.3 in 1.15; Tower V2 in 1.17; specs not verified | MeshCore blog |
| Elecrow ThinkNode M3/M4/M6/M7/M8, Muzi Base, Tiny Relay, Mesh Pocket | In repo; M4 and M8 new in 1.18; specs unverified | 1.18 notes, repo |
| Seeed small/discreet solar repeater | Only a comment in Seeed's blog, **no product announced** | Seeed blog (Mar 2026) |
| RAK WisMesh Pod | Meshtastic hardware, not MeshCore | search result |
| Higher-power PA boards | Exist (Station, Ikoka, T-Beam 1W, WioL1-1W); Part 15 limits apply | repo, FAQ |

## 5. Supporting gear
| Item | Findings | Price (source) |
|---|---|---|
| Fiberglass omni 915 | Rokland 6 dBi 900-930 MHz N-female; RAK fiberglass 3/5.8/8 dBi; Laird/TE **FG9026 6 dBd (~8.1 dBi)** | Rokland $15-35; RAK $27.50 (5.8 dBi); FG9026 $185-350 (radioparts/WPS) |
| Part 15 gain | Conducted power must stay within 15.247(b)(3) 1 W; the gain-reduction rule is in (b)(4); 6 dBi rule of thumb. **Verify** whether dBd/dBi and cable loss change EIRP | eCFR 47 CFR 15.247 |
| Cable | LMR-400 3.9 dB/100 ft at 900 MHz (Fairview/Times datasheet). Keep runs short; a few feet from the radio to the antenna beats 100 ft of cable | Not priced |
| Lightning arrestors | Proxicast ProGrade N-F/N-F $19.95 (verify rating); PolyPhaser IS-B50LN-C2 $149.99 (rated to 1 GHz) | Proxicast, American Radio Supply |
| Enclosures | RAK WisMesh Unify (IP67, solar); Seeed P1 (IPX6, 191x201x42 mm); medium Unify solar $29-52 | RAK, Seeed |
| LiFePO4 | LiTime 12V 6Ah (76.8 Wh) C$47.87: **charge cut at 0 C, no heater, charge and discharge only 0-50 C**; Epoch 12V 105Ah heated $549: charge to -20 C, needs ≥0.5 A charger, resumes at 5 C; Enjoybot self-heating 65Ah from $223; LiTime 100Ah heated €263 | vendor pages Nov 2026 |
| Charge controller | Victron SmartSolar MPPT 75/10: LiFePO4 profile with 5 C low-temp cutoff by default (Victron manual); needs a battery temp sensor for good cold behavior. Epever not priced | £42.83 UK (Infinite Solar); €72.90 EU |

## 6. First-cut solar/battery sizing (nRF52 repeater)
**Method:** daily Wh = I(mA) x V x 24 / 1000, divided by converter efficiency. Battery Wh = daily Wh x autonomy days / (DoD x cold derate). Panel W = daily Wh / (PSH x system derate).

**Example assumptions (marked A = assumption, S = sourced):**
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Avg draw | 5 mA @ 3.7 V (S: official PRs 5.8 mA powersaving) is the *optimistic* case: 0.44 Wh/day. **Design load 25 mA @ 3.7 V** (A: covers TX, cold, room-server style use; S: nodakmesh 25 mA) = 2.22 Wh/day |
| Converter | 12 V to 3.3/5 V, 85% (A) gives 2.6 Wh/day; round to **3 Wh/day** at the battery |
| Autonomy | 14 days (A, requested 7-14) = 42 Wh |
| DoD | 80% LiFePO4 (A; MeshAmerica guide uses same) |
| Cold capacity derate | 0.70 (A, **unverified**; cell data sheet needed) |
| Battery | 42 / (0.8 x 0.7) = **75 Wh** minimum. Choose 12 V 12 Ah LiFePO4 (~154 Wh) for 2x margin: 25 days at 3 Wh/day nominal |
| December sun | **0.89 kWh/m2/day horizontal** (S: NASA POWER). Tilted gain unverified (PVWatts not retrieved): use PSH **0.9** (worst) and **1.2** (A, likely for 60 deg tilt) |
| System derate | 0.70 (A: snow/rime, cold, MPPT, wiring; MeshAmerica uses 0.75) |
| Panel | 3 / (0.9 x 0.7) = **4.8 W** minimum; 3 / (1.2 x 0.7) = 3.6 W. Recharge check: 20 W gives 20 x 0.9 x 0.7 = 12.6 Wh/day, surplus 9.6 Wh/day, so about 4.4 days to refill 42 Wh |
| **Pick** | **20 W** panel (5x minimum margin) at 55-60 deg tilt, steep to shed snow; 12 V 12 Ah battery; 75/10 class MPPT (the 5 W / 13.4 Ah Li-ion SenseCAP is marginal and cold-charge limited) |

Note: NASA POWER values are for a regional grid cell, not a ridge. Fog, rime ice, and snow burial can cover a panel for weeks; that is why autonomy stays at 14 days and why a pilot with logging is needed. A ridge site may see much less. **Verify with PVWatts and site data (SNOTEL/Remote sensing) before procurement.**

## 7. Recommendation
**Standard repeater (nRF52, 12 V LiFePO4), rough per-site, parts only, unverified totals:**
| Part | Choice | Rough cost |
|---|---|---|
| Node | RAK WisMesh Repeater (RAK10721) or RAK4631 + RAK19007 reflashed to MeshCore repeater; keep a SenseCAP P1-Pro as the cheap turnkey alternate for low-priority valley sites | $99-300 (variant-dependent) |
| Antenna | 6 dBi 902-928 MHz fiberglass omni, N-female (Rokland class, or FG9026 where mast loading and quality matter) | $15-350 |
| Feedline | short LMR-400 jumper (<=10 ft) + N lightning arrestor (Proxicast to PolyPhaser) | $20-150 + cable |
| Battery | 12 V 12 Ah LiFePO4 in an insulated box with low-temp charge cutoff (heated optional); log temperature | ~$60-120 est. (unverified; only 6Ah and 100Ah+ prices found) |
| Solar | 20 W 12 V panel | unverified |
| Controller | Victron SmartSolar 75/10 with temp sensor or equivalent | ~$45-80 |
| Enclosure, mast, grounding | site-specific | unverified |
Roughly **$300-800 per site, unverified**, excluding towers, access, and labor. Run `powersaving on`, GPS off, 22 dBm (or lower), and test `rxps` only after the base config is proven.

**Standard field companion:** SenseCAP T1000-E + MeshCore phone app; T-Deck Plus for command posts.
**Room server:** nRF52 board at the EOC/Sheriff site on its own UPS/solar, repeater-only on ridges.

**Open items before Pilot:** per-site PVWatts run; cold-soak test of the battery down to the lowest local temp; FCC/antenna compliance review; confirm MeshCore firmware config (region/frequency preset: US/Canada preset 910.525 MHz, SF7, BW62.5, CR5 per FAQ) with neighbouring meshes; check vendor operating temperature for the RAK4631 (not found).

## Sources
github.com/meshcore-dev/MeshCore (main, 2026-11-14) and releases; blog.meshcore.io 1.18.0; docs.meshcore.io/faq (7.7, 2.3); docs.rakwireless.com RAK4631 and RAK19007 datasheets; store.rakwireless.com (Starter Kit, WisMesh Repeater, Repeater Mini V2); resource.heltec.cn T114 and MeshSolar datasheets; getuncabled.com MeshSolar; sensecap.io, seeedstudio.com P1-Pro; nodakmesh.org P1-Pro review and MeshCore solar build guide; wiki.meshamerica.com solar sizing; github.com/IoTThinks/EasySkyMesh PowerSaving17; MeshCore PRs #1238, #2286; ecfr.gov 47 CFR 15.247; power.larc.nasa.gov climatology; vendor battery pages (LiTime, Epoch, Enjoybot); Victron manual; Rokland, RAK, radioparts.com, Proxicast, American Radio Supply for RF parts.
